Should Roofing Companies Offer Money-Back Guarantees?

"Money-back guarantees rarely work for roofers. But other types of guarantees can be more effective and build customer trust. Discover better options for your business."

Share This Post

Adobestock 647303331 1 roofing followup
A man with hard hat standing on steps inspecting house roof

Running a roofing business isn’t for the faint of heart.

Subhead: And money-back guarantees might be making it worse.

You’re up early, working hard, making sure every shingle is perfect. The physical demands are high.

The pressure to maintain quality and safety is constant. Even with top-notch craftsmanship, keeping customers happy can be tricky. In this competitive field, standing out is everything.

One bold strategy gaining traction is offering money-back guarantees. It sounds appealing, but is it right for your roofing company? Let’s dig into the details, weigh the pros and cons, and explore some alternatives.

This isn’t about slapping a guarantee on your services. it’s about understanding how guarantees fit into your business strategy. The last thing you want to get caught with no money in your bank account when a customer asks for their money back!

What Are Money-Back Guarantees?

A money-back guarantee promises that if a customer isn’t satisfied, they get their money back. It’s common in retail and online services, where customer satisfaction is key. Think Amazon or Zappos—they’ve built massive trust with hassle-free returns. L.L. Bean ran a legendary lifetime money-back guarantee that they canceled in 2018. Buyers were outraged. They even got sued over it.

These industries thrive on simple products. It’s no sweat to Amazon if they lose $20 on your mancave sign.

But how does this apply to roofing? Unlike buying shoes, a new roof is a significant investment. It’s not something a customer can easily return.

Applying a money-back guarantee in roofing requires clear terms and careful consideration. You’ll need to define what “satisfaction” means in concrete terms. And you’ll need to prepare for potential disputes over subjective opinions on quality.

Pros of Offering Money-Back Guarantees

Boosts Trust

In the competitive roofing market, standing out is crucial. A money-back guarantee tells clients you believe in your work so much you’ll put your money on the line. This builds immense trust.

It also removes risk from their decision. Customers know they have nothing to lose, so they’re more likely to choose you over a competitor.

Enhances Satisfaction

A money-back guarantee shows you’re committed to quality. It signals that you’re not just there to do the job but to do it right. This leads to higher satisfaction and positive reviews—gold in the roofing business. Happy customers are more likely to refer your services to others through word-of-mouth.

In other words, you’re gambling. You’re making a bet that you’ll knock the socks off your customer so hard that they won’t want their money back. You’re also betting that your customer won’t take advantage of you and fake a problem.

And honestly, that logic works for some businesses. They close enough deals with their guarantee to cancel out the bad apples.

Cons of Offering Money-Back Guarantees

Financial Risks

The biggest drawback is the financial risk. Some customers might take advantage of the policy, demanding refunds for good work. This can lead to significant financial losses, especially for smaller roofing companies.

You’ll need to have a solid financial plan in place to manage potential refunds. That means keeping cash on hand, and lots of it. Instead of using that cash on the business, you’re using it just to cover your ass.

Implementation Complexity

Offering a money-back guarantee isn’t simple. You need clear, detailed terms to avoid disputes. What counts as “satisfaction”? How long does the guarantee last?

Plus, there are legal implications that might need extra resources. Crafting a sound guarantee policy takes time. It might mean working with legal experts. And those aren’t cheap!

Cash Flow Impact

Refunds can wreak havoc on your cash flow. Customers never ask for their money back at convenient times. It’s always when you’re thin on cash. And that can cause a chain reaction that cripples your business. Again, you’ve got to have a cash-heavy business to make a lifetime guarantee work.

Who Benefits from Money-Back Guarantees?

Small to Mid-Sized Companies

For a scrappy small business, a money-back guarantee can work wonders. It shows potential customers you’re willing to go above and beyond to earn their trust. This can be a game-changer. The added trust can lead to more contracts and a growing customer base. 

Just know that you’re making a bold play that could devastate your business if you play your cards wrong.

New Businesses

If you’re just starting, offering a money-back guarantee can attract first-time customers. It’s a bold move that can help you gain traction. By reducing the risk, you increase your chances of winning those first contracts. This can help you establish a strong foothold in the market and build a positive reputation.

Again, just make sure you have $20,000 in your back pocket. Few new businesses do.

Who Should Avoid Money-Back Guarantees?

Large Established Firms

If you’ve already built a reputation, a money-back guarantee might be overkill. Your brand strength and customer trust are in place. Introducing a policy could complicate your operations without significant benefits. Instead, it’s better to go all out on marketing and sales training to boost your profit.

High Operational Costs

If your business has high costs, the risk outweighs the reward. The potential for financial strain due to refunds can be too great a burden. For companies operating on thin margins, one refund can torch your business. So unless you’ve got cash out your ears, money-back guarantees are a massive liability.

Alternatives to Money-Back Guarantees

Extended Warranties

Consider offering extended warranties. That means you’ll repair any damage to the roof within a specific timeframe.

Suppliers often provide warranties on shingles and other products. Get a batch of shingles with defects, and the manufacturer replaces them for you.

This gives customers long-term assurance without immediate financial risk. It shows you stand by your work and are confident in its longevity. You get most of the benefits of the money-back guarantee with far less risk.

Service Guarantees

A service guarantee promises specific quality standards. You might guarantee that you’ll finish all repairs within a certain timeframe. This builds trust without the financial risks associated with refunds. Service guarantees focus on performance and reliability, reinforcing your commitment to excellence.

Just note that service guarantees demand expert project management. One week of rain could throw off your whole timeline.

Satisfaction Guarantees

A satisfaction guarantee involves making things right if the customer isn’t happy. This might include repairs or adjustments until the customer is happy. It helps lower the risk for the customer and the financial risk for your business.

These alternative guarantees come with downsides. First off, they’re not flashy like a money-back guarantee. And that means they like some of the shock and selling power.

Second, customers can still exploit them. Some folks aren’t happy with their roof until you’ve mowed their lawn, too. Be sure to specify in your quote the exact terms of your guarantee!


Money-back guarantees can be a double-edged sword for roofers. They can build trust and boost sales but come with risks. Sure, they help you stand out. But they could bankrupt your business if you don’t play your cards right.

Before diving into money-back guarantees, weigh your options. Consider alternatives like extended warranties, service guarantees, and satisfaction guarantees. You know your business best. If you feel that strongly about your quality and you’ve got cash in reserve, go for it. Otherwise, stick with another guarantee.


Remember, your quotes should outline your guarantee in detail. If you need help with creating quotes quickly, check out ProLine here.

Our quote templates make getting quotes sent and signed a breeze.

More To Explore

3 Types of Roofing CRM
The ProLine Blog

3 Types of Roofing CRMs

You might be using the wrong type of roofing CRM! Discover the different types of roofing CRM and which one works best for most roofers.

The Roofing CRM Industry Has a Huge Problem
The ProLine Blog

The Roofing CRM Industry Has a Huge Problem

Learn why roofers have such a hard time making their roofing CRM work. It’s mix of poor planning and little focus on what a roofing CRM should be.

Roofing Leads Made Easy
The ProLine Blog

Roofing Leads Made Easy

Use a solid referral strategy to get more roofing leads! Ask for referrals at key times, use incentives, and automate the whole process.

Want to Use PowrLine?

Let's chat about what PowrLine can do for your business.